By Jacob Ingledue
When people in the Springfield and Kansas City areas say they have a bird problem, they almost always mean one of five birds: the starling, the house sparrow, the pigeon, the woodpecker or the chimney swift. They look nothing alike and they cause different trouble. A starling stuffs a dryer vent with grass. A woodpecker drums on a corner of the siding at sunrise. A pigeon roosts on a ledge and leaves a mess below it. A chimney swift makes a ticking, chattering racket inside a flue in June. The right response to each is different, and in one important way the law treats them differently too.
That is the single most useful thing to know before you do anything. Three of these birds, the starling, the house sparrow and the pigeon, came here from Europe and are not covered by the federal law that protects native birds. The other two, woodpeckers and chimney swifts, are native, and they are protected. Many other wild birds that nest around houses, such as robins, cardinals, wrens and swallows, are protected as well, along with their active nests. The rules differ by species, they can change, and this guide is general information and not legal advice. For the current rules, the Missouri Department of Conservation, the Kansas Department of Wildlife and Parks and the US Fish and Wildlife Service are the places to ask.
Most mix-ups come from a quick look at a small brown or black bird flying away from the roofline. Here is what each one actually looks like.
The Missouri Department of Conservation field guide gives the starling’s length as about 8 and a half inches, with a stocky build and a short tail. In spring and summer the plumage looks black at a distance, but up close it is glossy and greenish, and the bill is long, sharp and yellow. After the fall molt the feathers are speckled with white spots that wear off toward spring, and the bill darkens to a brownish yellow in winter. Young starlings are a dull brownish gray with faint streaking underneath. The chunky shape and short tail are what separate a starling from other black birds in a yard.
The house sparrow is about 6 and a quarter inches long. The male has a chestnut back, a gray cap, a black eye line and a black bib on the throat and upper chest. The female is plainer, tan above with darker reddish-brown wings, a pale stripe over the eye and a plain tan underside. The Missouri Department of Conservation notes several birds that get mistaken for it, including the female dickcissel, the house finch with its streaked chest and the male’s red breast, and in winter the Harris’s sparrow. If the bird is a small brown bird nesting in a hole in your building and it is chirping in a flat, repeated, nonmusical way, it is nearly always a house sparrow.
The common city pigeon is larger than most people picture, roughly 12 to 14 inches long. The classic coloring is pale gray with two black bars across the wing, a white patch on the lower back, a dark band at the end of the tail and an iridescent green and purple sheen on the neck. Because feral pigeons descend from escaped domestic birds, plenty of them are red, brown, checkered or white instead. The coo is a soft, slightly wavering sound that most people know from window ledges.
Several species show up on houses in both states. The University of Missouri Extension lists the northern flicker, the red-headed woodpecker, the hairy and downy woodpeckers, the red-bellied woodpecker, the pileated woodpecker and, in winter, the yellow-bellied sapsucker. The northern flicker is about 12 and a half inches long, brown with black barring above, spotted below, with a white rump that flashes in flight and yellow under the wings and tail. The red-bellied woodpecker is about 9 and a quarter inches, with narrow black and white bars on the back and a red cap on the male that runs from the bill to the nape. The downy is the small one and the hairy is a larger look-alike with a longer bill. The pileated is crow-sized.
The chimney swift is a small, brown, cigar-shaped bird about 5 and a quarter inches long with a pale throat and a short, square tail. It is often mistaken for a swallow or a bat because it flies in fast, erratic loops after insects at dusk. It cannot perch on a branch the way a sparrow does. It clings to the vertical wall of a chimney instead, which is why it lives there.
Starlings, house sparrows, woodpeckers and chimney swifts are all found statewide in Missouri according to the Missouri Department of Conservation, and they are just as familiar across the Kansas City metro on the Kansas side. The starling and house sparrow are listed as common permanent residents, so they are here all year. The chimney swift is the exception, because it is a summer bird. The field guide says swifts arrive in Missouri in April and leave for South America in October.
The starling’s story here is a short one. The Missouri Department of Conservation notes that starlings were released in New York’s Central Park in 1890 and that by 1950 they had spread all the way to the Pacific Ocean. The house sparrow’s came earlier. The state field guide places its introduction from Europe in the 1800s, and other references point to a release of English birds in New York City in 1852.
What draws all of them to houses is the same thing: holes, ledges and warmth. Starlings and house sparrows are cavity nesters and both are happy to use human-made sites. A gap at a soffit, a loose piece of fascia, a gable vent without a screen or the end of a dryer duct is exactly the hole they are looking for. Pigeons want a sheltered ledge where a flat platform of sticks will stay dry. Swifts want a vertical flue with rough walls. Woodpeckers are a different case, because they are not looking for a hole to nest in. They are drawn to the wood itself, as you will see below.
Near Springfield, Nixa, Ozark and Republic, the woodlots and creek corridors put hardwoods close to houses, and that is where woodpecker trouble clusters. The University of Missouri Extension says most building damage happens within about half a mile of wooded areas with large hardwood trees. In the Kansas City metro the older neighborhoods with mature trees and brick chimneys are where swifts and woodpeckers are most often noticed, while commercial strips and parking structures give pigeons their ledges.
Starlings eat nearly anything. The Missouri Department of Conservation says they forage on the ground for white grubs and other soil animals and also take berries, seeds and scraps such as discarded fries. They nest in cavities, including crannies in buildings and signs, woodpecker holes and nest boxes, and they compete hard for those sites. A clutch holds 3 to 6 eggs, incubation takes about 12 days and the young fledge in 21 to 23 days. There can be one or two broods a year, so a starling nest in a vent can be active in spring and again in early summer. Many starlings are skilled mimics.
House sparrows eat grain, weed seeds, fruit, insects and bread crumbs. Their nests are untidy bundles of grass, twigs, feathers and trash that often end up in a vent, a soffit or a gap behind a sign. A clutch can hold up to 8 eggs, with up to 4 broods a year. Eggs incubate for 10 to 14 days and the young stay in the nest another 10 to 14 days. The oldest wild house sparrow on record lived at least 15 years, though most live far shorter lives. Across the continent they also compete with native cavity nesters such as bluebirds, which is one reason people who put up bluebird boxes have strong opinions about them.
Pigeons eat mostly grains, seeds and fruit and will take scraps. Reference sources describe their nests as flimsy platforms of straw and sticks on sheltered ledges, including on bridges, abandoned buildings and farm structures. Each clutch is two white eggs, shared incubation runs 17 to 19 days, and a pair can raise young up to six times a year, in any month, though spring and summer are the peak. Wild pigeons live roughly three to five years. A single pair on a ledge becomes a roost quickly because they return to the same spot, and the mess builds with every season.
Woodpeckers hammer for several reasons. The University of Missouri Extension explains that they excavate nest or roost cavities, search for wood-boring insects, grubs, spiders and ants, and drum to mark territory and attract a mate. Drumming works like song, and it peaks in spring. A common idea is that they only peck houses to reach insects. The extension guide specifically calls that a misconception, because many species drill into sound, dry wood where there are no insects at all. It also notes that houses may seem like “super trees,” since a large wooden surface carries sound well, and cedar-sided homes see a high incidence of damage.
Northern flickers eat a large share of ants, which they take from the ground, and they nest in cavities in snags, poles, posts, banks and sometimes houses. Missouri usually has one brood a year, with nesting peaking around the second week of June. A flicker clutch is commonly 5 to 8 eggs, incubated 11 to 14 days, and the young fledge 25 to 28 days after hatching. Red-bellied woodpeckers lay 2 to 6 eggs, incubate for about 12 days and fledge their young 24 to 27 days later. Yellow-bellied sapsuckers are winter visitors that usually arrive in October and leave by late April, and they drill neat rows of small holes in live trees for sap, not in your siding.
Chimney swifts eat flying insects, which they catch in the air. They build small twig nests glued together with saliva and attached to the wall of a chimney, and only one pair nests in each chimney. The Missouri Department of Conservation gives 3 to 5 eggs per clutch, with about 15 to 20 days of incubation and about the same time before the young fledge. A swift nest is not like a starling’s mess. It is a small bracket of twigs on the wall and the birds are quiet until the young hatch. Then there is a constant chattering and ticking that carries down into the fireplace. In fall, hundreds of swifts may circle over a large chimney before they drop in to roost. Swift numbers have been falling steeply since the 1960s, which is one reason their chimneys matter.
Each bird gives you different clues, and the clue tells you which one you have.
“Woodpeckers only peck wood when there are bugs inside.” The University of Missouri Extension calls this a common misconception. Territory, courtship, roosting cavities and the sound a surface makes all drive the behavior, and many woodpeckers drum on sound wood with no insects in it. Spraying for insects will not always end it.
“All birds on my house can be removed because they are a nuisance.” Not so. Starlings, house sparrows and pigeons are not protected by the federal migratory bird law because they are non-native, but most native birds and their active nests are protected. Robins, cardinals, wrens, swallows, woodpeckers and swifts are on that protected side. Do not guess a species from a distance.
“Plastic owls and fake hawks will scare everything away.” The University of Missouri Extension describes stationary model hawks and owls, fake snakes and silhouettes as generally ineffective for woodpeckers. Birds quickly learn that a model does not move. Moving, shiny and reflective items hold up better.
“I will just let them leave when they are ready.” Starlings and sparrows come back to the same hole every year. A cavity that worked once will work again. Leaving it open is an invitation.
On health, the one disease that comes up most with roosting pigeons and starlings is histoplasmosis, a fungal illness tied to old, accumulated droppings. That is as far as this guide goes. For any health question about droppings, dust or breathing, ask your doctor. It is a question for your doctor, and not something to settle with a web search.
On the law, the starting point is federal. The US Fish and Wildlife Service explains that the Migratory Bird Treaty Act prohibits taking protected migratory birds without authorization, and that it applies only to native species. The Service publishes a list of non-native, human-introduced species that it does not apply to. The starling, house sparrow and rock pigeon are the three that most Missouri and Kansas homeowners deal with, and they are the ones people usually mean when they say a bird is “not protected.”
Woodpeckers and chimney swifts sit on the other side. The University of Missouri Extension states that woodpeckers are protected by state and federal law and that lethal removal can only be considered after non-lethal methods fail and significant damage has occurred, and then only with a federal permit. Reference sources say that neither chimney swifts nor their nests can be removed from a chimney without a federal permit. Active nests of other native birds, including robins, cardinals and swallows, get the same kind of protection.
States add their own rules on top. Kansas has a nuisance bird list that treats the starling, the house sparrow and the feral pigeon as non-native species, and it sets its own permit rules for certain control methods. Missouri has its own regulations and its own Department of Conservation guidance. Local ordinances can matter too, including rules about discharge, trapping and what can be used in a city. Everything here is general and it can change. For the current rules, contact the Missouri Department of Conservation, the Kansas Department of Wildlife and Parks or the US Fish and Wildlife Service before you act.
The same few principles apply to every species.
Work out which bird it is before touching anything. If you cannot tell, treat it as protected until you know otherwise.
Eggs or young change everything. If the bird is a protected species and the nest is active, the practical answer is usually to wait until the young have left, and then close the entry. A swift family in a chimney is a common example. The young leave the nest after about a month, and the birds are gone for the year by October. The time to put a cap on the flue is after that, before the next April.
Closing the hole is the part that works. Catching birds without fixing the opening only makes room for the next pair. Screen vents and louvers with a sturdy mesh, replace damaged soffit, cap the chimney with a cap that has a mesh screen and fill the gaps along fascia and trim. For pigeons, the work is about making ledges unusable, with slopes, netting or spikes where appropriate. For woodpeckers, the University of Missouri Extension suggests removing ledges, cracks and crevices that give them a toehold, hanging strips of aluminum foil or holographic reflective tape a few feet above the spot, and attaching lightweight netting at the eaves, angled to the siding. It describes the netting as a long-term answer. For repeated damage on a small area, a patch of metal flashing can cover it. If you see long jagged gashes on a deck or beam, check for carpenter bees, because woodpeckers go after them.
Once the birds are gone and the opening is closed, the nest material and droppings still need to come out. If birds got into the attic itself, our guide on how to get birds out of your attic walks through the signs and the steps.
A professional is worth calling when the bird is in the attic or walls, when you cannot reach the entry point from the ground, when droppings have built up, or when you are not sure what species you have and whether it is protected. It is also worth a call when a woodpecker has made a hole and you are not sure what is behind the siding.
Whoever you call, ask these questions:
A good answer to the last one is honest about the limits. A company should be able to tell you which of these birds it can work on and which it cannot.
On our bird removal page, Titan Pest Pro says it handles the three non-native species, rock pigeons, European starlings and house sparrows, through exclusion and deterrents. It says the process begins with an inspection and species identification, followed by an estimate, removal or exclusion, installation of exclusion and deterrent measures and cleanup. For situations involving protected birds, such as active robin and cardinal nests, woodpecker siding damage and swallow nests with eggs or young, the page says Titan coordinates rather than treats. Titan’s wildlife work also covers related animals, which you can see on its squirrel removal page if the noise in the attic turns out not to be a bird.
If you are in the Springfield area, our Springfield pest control page covers the service area. On the Kansas City side, there is a page for Kansas City pest control.
Are starlings, house sparrows and pigeons protected?
Under the federal migratory bird law, they are not covered because they are non-native species. That does not remove every rule, because states and cities can have their own, and many other wild birds are protected. Check with the Missouri Department of Conservation, the Kansas Department of Wildlife and Parks or the US Fish and Wildlife Service for the current rules.
Can I remove a chimney swift nest?
Reference sources say neither the birds nor the nests may be removed from a chimney without a federal permit. In practice, most people wait until the birds leave for the winter in October and then cap the chimney. If you are unsure, ask the US Fish and Wildlife Service or the Missouri Department of Conservation.
Why is a woodpecker drumming on my house?
The University of Missouri Extension lists several reasons, including territory, courtship, searching for insects and making a cavity. Houses with natural wood siding, especially cedar, are hit more often. Spring is the peak season for drumming.
Will a plastic owl keep birds away?
The University of Missouri Extension rates stationary model hawks, owls and fake snakes as generally ineffective against woodpeckers. Things that move and flash in the light, such as holographic tape or foil strips, are described as more useful. Netting at the eaves is the long-term answer it describes.
What should I do about a nest in my dryer vent?
First work out which bird it is and whether the nest is active. If the species is a starling or house sparrow, the nest can be removed and the vent screened. If the bird is a protected native species, check the rules and usually wait until the young have left before closing the opening.
Are bird droppings a health risk?
Droppings that build up over time are linked to a fungal illness called histoplasmosis. Any question about your own health or symptoms is a question for your doctor. Do not handle droppings with bare hands or sweep dry droppings into the air.
Do I need a permit to deal with birds on my house?
It depends on the species. For starlings, house sparrows and pigeons, the federal law does not apply, but state and local rules can. For woodpeckers, swifts and most other native birds, lethal control and removal of active nests need a federal permit, and exclusion is the approach most people take. This is general information, not legal advice.
When is the best time to seal up a bird entry point?
The best time is when no young are inside. For swifts that is after they leave in October. For starlings and sparrows it is between broods or in late winter before they start nesting. A pair may raise more than one brood, so check again before closing.